Search This Blog

Tuesday, 27 November 2018

Headbang - 23 Nov, 2018 - Best Of voting

The votes are now in from all 10 of the Headbangers for their Favourite Tracks and Themes.

Once more, it demonstrates what a broad church we are, with 14 separate tracks receiving at least one nomination. The final result is:

1  Faces Losing you  12
2 Various Artistes While my guitar gently weeps 10
3 K T Tunstall Black Horse and the Cherry Tree 7
4 Radiohead Nobody does it better 6
5 Temperance Movement Only Friend 5
6 Iggy Stooge The passenger 4
7= Tony Joe White Rainy night in Georgia 3
7= Duke Robillard Anything it takes 3
9 Ronnie Lane Ooh la la 2
10= Blondie Atomic 2
10= Simon & Garfunkel The boxer 2
10= Doors Unknown Soldier 2
13= Jake Bugg  Universal Soldier 1
13= Stevie Nicks/Fleetwood Mac Rhiannon 1

As for the Themes, the voting was skewed a little with Gary and Malcolm missing the later themes and not being able to vote on them:

1 La La Land 55
2 Armistice Day Centenary 51
3= Septuagenarians 49
3= Rock Chicks 49
5 White Album 50 38
6 New(ish) Scottish Artistes 37
7 Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Nominations 2019 35
8 Obituary 33
As ever, the Obituary section is at the mercy of the stature of those who have passed recently, but it's also noticeable that the New(ish) Artistes struggled again - I had proposed dropping this section after previous poor marks, but, after a couple of appeals, I relented but reduced the number of tracks played in this theme, but that doesn't seem to have helped.

Again, however, the scoring was hugely varied with 3 of the themes - Armistice, Rock Chicks and Obituary - scoring both best and worst marks by different Headbangers. Another 4 of the themes - Septuagenarians, White Album, New(ish) and RnRHoF showed only fractionally less diversity, and even in the "winning" theme - La La Land - scoring varied from best to 3rd worst.

No comments:

Post a Comment